"Herkesin kendi gerçeği varsa, benimki neden bu kadar erken kalkıyor?" – Dorothy Parker"

There Is No Funeral Prayer

Kuran'da "salāt" kavramının bağlama göre değişen anlamları üzerine bir inceleme. At-Tawbah suresi 9:84 ayetinde geçen "salāt" ifadesinin geleneksel namaz anlayışından farklı olarak, "dua etmek" anlamına geldiği açıklanıyor. Allah'ın, Nebimiz Muhammed'e inkâr içinde ölenlerin mezarı başında durmayı ve onlar için dua etmeyi yasaklamasının anlamı üzerine düşündürücü bir bakış.

yazı resim

One of the fundamental concepts in Islam is “salāt.” Although it is commonly understood as “ritual prayer” (namaz) in traditional Islam, in the Qur’an it carries different meanings depending on the context. In Surah At-Tawbah, verse 84, Allah says:
«“And do not perform salāt over any of them who has died, nor stand at his grave. Indeed, they disbelieved in Allah and His Messenger and died while they were defiantly disobedient.” (At-Tawbah, 9:84)»
In this verse, the expression “to perform salāt” is not used in the sense of ritual prayer (namaz), but rather in the meaning of supplication (du‘ā). Allah instructs Prophet Muhammad not to pray for those who died as rebellious disbelievers and not to stand by their graves. The verse emphasizes that these individuals rejected Islam and denied Allah and His Messenger, and because they died in a state of defiance (fisq), the Prophet is told not to seek mercy or forgiveness for them.
In Islam, making supplication—turning to Allah, asking for His help and forgiveness—is an essential part of a believer’s life. The phrase “to perform salāt” also reminds Prophet Muhammad and his الأمة (community) of the duty to pray to Allah and seek His mercy. However, in this verse, attention is drawn to the conditions of such supplication. Muslims are instructed not to pray for those who rejected faith and denied Islam.
In this context, “salāt” does not merely refer to praying for someone after death; it also highlights the importance of a person’s beliefs and moral state during their lifetime. The command not to stand behind or pray for those who opposed Allah and His Messenger reflects the idea that their disbelief prevents them from deserving Allah’s mercy and forgiveness.
In Islam, supplication is also a means of comfort and a search for divine mercy. However, such supplication must carry meaning and be rooted in sincere faith and submission to Allah. When believers make du‘ā, they are genuinely asking Allah for forgiveness and mercy.
The prohibition of “performing salāt” in Surah At-Tawbah 9:84 also indicates that praying for those whose ultimate state in the Hereafter is not aligned with faith is unnecessary. According to this understanding, supplication holds meaning primarily for those who are on the right path and who submit to Allah.
Although the word “salāt” in this verse is traditionally interpreted as referring to the “funeral prayer,” in reality, there is no funeral prayer in Islam. Here, the term clearly carries the meaning of making supplication. The Prophet was commanded not to pray for those who rejected faith and died in a state of فساد (corruption), as their opposition to Allah prevents their forgiveness.
This verse provides an important insight into the nature of supplication in Islam and the conditions under which it is meaningful.
In conclusion, there is no funeral prayer. The term “salāt” in Surah At-Tawbah 9:84 means supplication. Supplication is an act of worship performed with sincere faith and submission, and it holds meaning only for those who are on the right path.

KİTAP İZLERİ

ZEYTİNDAĞI

Falih Rıfkı Atay

Bir İmparatorluğun Veda Mektubu: Falih Rıfkı Atay'dan Zeytindağı Her milletin tarihinde, hatırlamaktan kaçındığı, üzerine bir sessizlik perdesi çekmeyi yeğlediği dönemler vardır. Bizim için Osmanlı İmparatorluğu'nun
İncelemeyi Oku

Yorumlar

Başa Dön